Metal roof repair
Metal roof repair: fixing the fasteners, laps and trim that let water in
A metal panel almost never wears through in the open. Metal roofs leak where something holds the panels down or joins them together: a screw washer that has dried out, a lap whose sealant has let go, a ridge or wall trim that was caulked instead of flashed. Repairing a metal roof means finding which of those has failed and fixing it with parts that suit the metal you have. Tell us what your roof is doing and we call or email you back about it.
Which kind of metal roof do you have?
The first question in any metal roof repair is the system, because each one fails in its own places and is repaired in its own way. You can usually tell from the ground or from a photo taken from an upstairs window.
| System | How to recognise it | Where it usually fails |
|---|---|---|
| Exposed-fastener panels (corrugated or ribbed) | Rows of screw heads with washers visible across the panels; common on garages, sheds, patios and barns | Screw washers, screws that missed the framing, side and end laps, ridge and wall trim |
| Standing seam | Smooth flat pans with raised seams every foot or two and no visible screws in the field | End laps and splices, the seam at the ridge, trim at walls and chimneys, penetrations cut through a pan |
| Metal shingles or shakes | Small stamped pieces made to look like shingles, tile or shake | Interlocks bent by foot traffic, valleys, flashing at walls and vents |
Knowing the system also tells a roofer what can and cannot be swapped. A ribbed panel can often be replaced one sheet at a time; a standing seam pan usually runs from eave to ridge in one piece, so replacing it means opening the seams on both sides.
Why do metal roofs leak at the screws?
On an exposed-fastener roof, each screw is sealed by a rubber or neoprene washer pressed against the panel. That washer is the softest part of the roof and the first to age. Sun hardens and cracks it, heat makes the panel grow and shrink around it every day, and in a few years some washers stop sealing. Installation shortcuts make it worse: a screw driven too tight crushes the washer out to the sides, one driven too loose never seals, one driven at an angle seals on one side only, and one that missed the framing underneath has nothing to grip and slowly backs out.
The usual repair is to replace the failed screws rather than smear sealant over them. Where a hole has been stripped, a roofer may use a slightly larger screw; where a screw missed the framing, the old hole has to be sealed and a new screw placed where it bites. Ask whoever comes out whether they are replacing only the screws that are leaking or every screw on the roof, and why. On an older roof with many dry washers, fixing the one drip often just moves the leak to the next screw.
Laps, seams and trim: the other half of most leaks
Panels overlap at their sides and, on long runs, at their ends. Those laps depend on the slope of the roof and on sealant or tape inside the overlap. The model code most US homes are built to, the International Residential Code, sets minimum slopes for metal panel roofs in section R905.10.2: lapped, non-soldered panels without applied lap sealant need at least 3 units of rise in 12 (a 25 percent slope); with lap sealant applied to the maker's instructions they may go down to one-half unit in 12; and standing seam systems may go as low as one-quarter unit in 12. The California Residential Code carries the same three figures.
That matters for repairs. A lapped panel roof on a shallow patio or porch cover that was built below 3 in 12 relies entirely on the sealant in its laps; when that sealant ages, wind-driven rain gets pushed uphill through the overlap. Fixing it means opening the lap, cleaning it and resealing it with a sealant the panel maker allows, not running a bead along the outside edge. Trim is the same story. Ridge caps, rake trim, wall flashing and the closures under the ridge keep out wind-blown rain and nesting birds. When trim was caulked against a wall instead of tucked under the siding or a counter flashing, the caulk eventually splits and the water runs behind it.
Rust, scratches and metals that should not touch
Steel roofing is protected by a metallic coating (zinc or a zinc and aluminium blend) under its paint. Rust starts where that protection is broken: at cut edges, at scratches from foot traffic or a fallen branch, around old screw holes, and where water sits. Surface rust caught early can usually be cleaned and treated; rust that has eaten through a panel or a lap means that section of metal has to be replaced.
A less obvious cause is two metals that should not be together. When different metals touch in the presence of water, one of them corrodes faster than it would alone. The Metal Construction Association, the trade group for metal building products, warns in its technical bulletin on dissimilar metal corrosion that copper, and even rain running off copper, quickly corrodes zinc-coated steel. In practice that means a copper flashing, a copper pipe or a copper gutter above a steel roof, the wrong fasteners, or an old satellite or antenna mount can start a rust stain that keeps coming back. A repair that uses matching metal, fasteners the panel maker approves and a separating layer where two metals must meet stops it at the source.
Hail and wind on metal roofs
Hail dents metal; it rarely punches through it. Whether a dent matters depends on whether it opened a seam, cracked the paint or bent a lap, or only changed how the roof looks. Many insurance policies treat purely cosmetic dents on metal differently from damage that lets water in, so read your policy and ask your insurer before assuming anything. In Texas, impact-resistant roofing is rated Class 1 to 4, and insurers set their own premium credits and paperwork for it, as the Texas Department of Insurance explains. The homeowner files any claim; a roofer can document what they find. Our hail damage roof repair page covers storm dates and the Texas deductible rules.
Wind is the other storm risk. It works on edges first: rake and eave trim, the end of a panel at the eave, and ridge caps. Loose trim that rattles in a storm is a warning sign. Re-fastening it before the next wind season is a small job; replacing panels that peeled back is not.
Is oil canning damage?
Oil canning is a visible waviness in the flat part of metal panels, most noticeable on standing seam pans in low morning or evening light. It comes from stresses in the metal itself and from how it was formed and fastened. It is generally treated as a matter of looks, not a leak, and it cannot be pressed flat once the panels are on. If waviness appears suddenly in one area, though, have it looked at: a panel that has started moving because its clips or fasteners let go is a different problem from one that has always looked that way.
Repair, coat or replace?
A metal roof repair is worth doing when the panels themselves are sound and the trouble is in the fasteners, laps, trim or a few damaged sheets. Roof coatings made for metal can be an option for a weathered but intact roof, but they bridge small gaps only; they do not fix loose fasteners, rusted-through panels or a lap that was built below its slope. When rust is spread across many panels, or the roof keeps leaking in new places after each repair, the conversation turns to replacing it. Our guide to repairing or replacing a roof walks through that choice.
In California, replacing a roof needs a building permit, and when 50 percent or more of a roof is replaced the Energy Code's cool roof rules can apply. In the Bay Area that is only in Climate Zones 4 and 12; for steep-slope roofs there, the new roofing needs an aged solar reflectance of at least 0.20 and thermal emittance of at least 0.75 (or an SRI of at least 16), shown on a Cool Roof Rating Council label. The cool roof page explains the rule.
What to do before anyone comes out
- Do not walk on a metal roof to look. Panels are slippery even when dry, very slippery when wet or dusty, and foot traffic in the wrong place dents panels and bends seams.
- From inside, note where water shows and whether it appears in every rain or only with wind from one side. Wind-only leaks on metal often point to trim or laps.
- From the ground, take photos of rust stains, loose trim, lifted panel ends and anything mounted on the roof.
- Write down what you know about the roof: the system, its rough age, any past repairs and any copper or other metal nearby.
- If water is pouring in, read emergency roof repair; covering a metal roof is done differently from a shingle roof so that no new holes are made.
What a written metal roof repair scope should say
Ask for a short written scope before work starts. It should name the system and the areas being repaired, which fasteners will be replaced (all, or which rows) and with what type, how laps will be opened and resealed and with which kind of sealant, what trim or flashing is being replaced and with which metal, how any rust will be treated, and how foot traffic will be kept off panels that are not being worked on. In California, check the contractor's license on the state board's site first; roofing is the C-39 classification, and a home improvement down payment is capped at $1,000 or 10 percent of the price, whichever is less. Texas has no state roofing license, so ask for proof of insurance and a written scope. Photos of the opened laps and the finished work are the simplest proof that the hidden parts were done right.
Metal roof repair
Metal roof dripping or rusting? Call us
Tell us what the roof is doing and where the home is. We call or email you back about it; the request is free and commits nobody to anything.
Tell us about your metal roof
Tell us what the roof is doing, what it is made of if you know, and the city or ZIP. We call or email you back about it; the request is free and commits you to nothing.
Metal roof repair questions
Should leaking screws on a metal roof be tightened or replaced?
Usually replaced. Tightening a screw with a cracked, dried washer squeezes the washer further and rarely seals it for long, and over-tightening splits it. A new screw with a fresh washer, driven straight and snug into the framing, is the normal fix. Ask whether the other washers on the roof are near the same age.
Is the wavy look on my metal roof a sign of damage?
Not by itself. Even waviness across flat pans, called oil canning, is generally a matter of looks rather than a leak, and it cannot be flattened once the panels are on. Waviness that appears suddenly in one spot is different: it can mean clips or fasteners have let go, so have that area checked.
Can a coating fix an old metal roof instead of replacing it?
Sometimes, if the panels are sound. A coating made for metal can renew a weathered surface and seal small gaps, but it does not fix loose or failed fasteners, rusted-through panels or a lap built below its slope. Those need repair first, or the coating only hides the problem for a while.
Sources: International Code Council, 2021 International Residential Code, Chapter 9 Roof Assemblies (R905.10.2, metal roof panel slopes), and 2022 California Residential Code R905.10.2; Metal Construction Association, Dissimilar Metal Corrosion in Roofing Installations (technical bulletin, 2016); Texas Department of Insurance, Products qualifying for impact-resistant roofing credits (as of 2023-02-24) and Roofing and insurance: Know the law (updated 2025-03-24); BayREN, Residential Roofing: Guide to 2022 Energy Code Requirements (updated 2022-12-20); Contractors State License Board, C-39 Roofing classification and Industry Bulletin #22-14 (2022-11-22).